Puppy Biscuits vs Benebone Ring: Which Treat Wins?
By Dog Supplies Warehouse | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Comparisons
Compare Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Puppy Biscuits and Benebone Bacon Ring to find the best option for training, chewing, and bonding with your puppy.
Quick answer
For training and rewarding good behavior, choose Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Puppy Biscuits. For durable chewing and mental stimulation, choose the Benebone Bacon Ring. Each serves a different purpose, so your decision depends on your puppy's current needs.
Training treats vs chew toys: different jobs
Puppy treats and chew toys serve different roles in your dog's development. Training treats like the Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Rewards Puppy Original Biscuits are designed for quick rewards during obedience sessions or as a tasty snack. Chew toys like the Benebone Bacon Ring are built for sustained chewing, which helps with teething relief, jaw exercise, and keeping your puppy occupied.
Key trade-offs to consider
The Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Puppy Biscuits are edible and meant to be consumed, making them ideal for training but not for long-lasting entertainment. The Benebone Bacon Ring is not edible—it's a durable nylon chew toy infused with real bacon flavor. It also features a pocket you can fill with peanut butter for added appeal. However, because it's not edible, it won't replace the need for training treats.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Purpose: Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Puppy Biscuits are for training rewards and snacks. Benebone Bacon Ring is for durable chewing and mental stimulation.
- Edibility: Puppy biscuits are fully edible and safe to consume. Benebone Bacon Ring is not edible—it's built for chewing, not eating. Always supervise your puppy with any chew toy, especially non-edible ones.
- Longevity: Biscuits are consumed quickly, ideal for short training sessions. The Benebone Ring lasts much longer, providing hours of chewing entertainment. If you need a treat that lasts, the Benebone Ring is the better choice.
Product facts at a glance
- Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Rewards Puppy Original Biscuits 2 lb: Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Rewards Puppy Original Biscuits 2 lb are a treat designed to reward good behavior during training or to show your puppy extra love. These biscuits are a practical, edible reward for training sessions, helping reinforce positive behavior without the need for supervision during consumption.
Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Rewards Puppy Original Biscuits 2 lb - Benebone Bacon Ring Large: The Benebone Ring is infused with real bacon and has a built-in pocket you can fill with peanut butter for a bacon plus PB combo dogs go crazy for. The durable nylon construction and bacon flavor make it a long-lasting chew toy that can also be made more exciting with a spreadable filling, perfect for keeping your puppy engaged.
Benebone Bacon Ring Large
Which one is right for your puppy?
Best for
- Training sessions and quick rewards: Midwestern Pet Wholesomes Puppy Biscuits
- Durable chewing and teething relief: Benebone Bacon Ring
Not ideal for
- Long-lasting entertainment: Puppy biscuits are consumed too quickly
- Training rewards: Benebone Bacon Ring is not edible and cannot be used as a treat
