Benebone Wishbone Giant vs MapleStick Giant: Which Chew?
By Dog Supplies Warehouse | Published: 2026-10-24
Category: Comparisons
Compare Benebone Wishbone Giant and MapleStick Giant dog chews. Learn which durable nylon chew suits your large dog's grip and flavor preferences.
Quick answer
Choose the Benebone Wishbone Giant if your dog likes to grip with their paws and loves peanut butter flavor. Choose the MapleStick Giant if your dog prefers a stick shape and enjoys maple wood flavor.
Shape and grip: paws vs. instinct
The Wishbone Giant's curved shape is designed to let your dog prop it up with their paws and get a good grip. This makes it easier for dogs that like to hold their chew while gnawing.
The MapleStick Giant mimics a natural stick, a shape many dogs instinctively love. It may be easier for dogs that prefer to carry or fetch, though it lacks the built-in paw grip of the Wishbone.
Flavor: peanut butter vs. maple wood
The Wishbone Giant is packed with real peanut butter flavor from end to end, making it a strong choice for dogs that go wild for that taste.
The MapleStick Giant is infused with real maple wood for flavor, offering a different, woodsy taste that appeals to dogs that like sticks. Neither chew is edible—both are built for chewing, not eating.
Size and safety considerations
Both chews come in Giant size, best for dogs under 120 lbs. Always supervise your dog with any chew toy, and replace it if it becomes worn down to a small piece to avoid choking hazards.
Both are made in the USA from durable nylon, and Benebone backs them with a happiness guarantee, so you can try either with confidence.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Grip preference: If your dog likes to hold chews with their paws, the Wishbone's curved shape is easier to grip. If they prefer to carry or fetch, the MapleStick's stick shape may be more appealing. Watch how your dog plays with existing toys to gauge their grip preference.
- Flavor preference: Go with peanut butter if your dog is treat-motivated by that taste. Choose maple wood if they enjoy the scent of sticks or woodsy flavors. Consider offering both flavors to see which your dog finishes first.
- Durability and safety: Both are durable nylon, not edible, and sized Giant for dogs under 120 lbs. Supervise chewing and replace when worn down to prevent choking. Inspect the chew regularly and discard if it becomes small enough to swallow.
Product facts at a glance
- Benebone Wishbone Giant Peanut Butter: Curved, paw-friendly shape that’s easy to hold and packed with real peanut butter flavor from end to end. This shape lets your dog grip the chew with their paws, making it ideal for dogs that like to hold their toys while chewing.
Benebone Wishbone Giant Peanut Butter - Benebone MapleStick Giant: Stick shape dogs instinctively love, infused with real maple wood for flavor. The familiar stick shape appeals to natural chewers, and the maple flavor offers a unique alternative to meaty tastes.
Benebone MapleStick Giant
Which chew fits your dog?
Best for
- Dogs that like to hold chews with their paws and love peanut butter flavor (Wishbone Giant)
- Dogs that prefer a stick shape and enjoy woodsy flavors (MapleStick Giant)
Not for
- Dogs over 120 lbs, as the Giant size may be too small
- Aggressive chewers that can break nylon quickly—consider a harder chew material
