Wellness GF Chicken vs Natural Balance Buffalo Canned Dog Food
By Dog Supplies Warehouse | Published: 2026-10-28
Category: Buying Guides
Compare Wellness GF Chicken and Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes canned dog food. See which grain-free wet food fits your dog's needs.
Quick Answer
Choose Wellness GF Chicken if you want a 95% meat recipe topper or mixer that adds protein and variety. Choose Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes if you prefer a complete and balanced grain-free meal with a novel protein like bison.
Protein Source and Digestibility
The main difference between these two canned foods is the protein source. Wellness GF Chicken uses chicken, a common protein that most dogs tolerate well. Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes uses bison, a novel protein that can be a good option for dogs with food sensitivities to more typical meats like chicken or beef.
Both recipes are grain-free, but they serve different purposes. Wellness GF Chicken is designed as a mixer or topper, while Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes is a complete and balanced meal for adult dogs. Knowing your dog's specific dietary needs will help you decide which one fits better.
Complete Meal vs Mixer/Topper
Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes is a complete and balanced recipe, meaning it provides all the essential nutrients your adult dog needs when fed as the sole diet. It also includes sweet potatoes, a highly digestible source of energy, and vegetable broth for extra flavor.
Wellness GF Chicken, on the other hand, is a 95% meat recipe that is best used as a mixer or topper. It's a healthy, natural way to add meat content and variety to your dog's regular kibble or meal. It is not intended to be a complete meal on its own.
Consider your feeding routine: if you want a convenient all-in-one wet food, Natural Balance is the better choice. If you want to enhance your dog's existing diet with extra protein, Wellness GF Chicken is the way to go.
Trade-Offs at a Glance
- Complete nutrition vs. flexibility: Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes is a complete meal; Wellness GF Chicken is a topper. Choose based on whether you need a standalone food or a supplement.
- Novel protein vs. common protein: Bison in Natural Balance may be better for dogs with chicken sensitivities; chicken in Wellness is a familiar protein but may not suit allergic dogs. If your dog has known allergies, consider the protein source carefully.
- Price per can: Wellness GF Chicken is priced at $2.57 per can, while Natural Balance Buffalo is $2.79. The slight difference may matter if you buy in bulk. Check your budget and feeding frequency to decide which fits better.
Product Facts
- Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes Can: Premium protein from bison to help support lean muscle mass, with sweet potatoes for a highly digestible source of energy. Grain-free, complete and balanced for adult dogs. This makes it a suitable single-food option for adult dogs, especially those needing a novel protein source.
Natural Balance Buffalo and Sweet Potatoes Can - Wellness GF Chicken: 95% meat recipe, grain-free, cooked right in the can to lock in freshness and taste. Designed to be used as a mixer or topper. It's a convenient way to add high-quality protein and variety to your dog's regular meals without preparing raw or cooked meat.
Wellness GF Chicken
Which One Should You Choose?
Best for
- Dogs that need a complete and balanced grain-free meal with a novel protein source (Natural Balance Buffalo)
- Owners who want to add extra meat protein to their dog's existing diet (Wellness GF Chicken)
Not for
- Dogs with known chicken allergies should avoid Wellness GF Chicken
- Owners looking for a complete meal should not rely solely on Wellness GF Chicken as it is a topper
