Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-16 Dog Supplies Warehouse 1 views

Open Farm Raw Lamb vs Herring and Mackerel Wet Dog Food

Open Farm Raw Lamb vs Herring and Mackerel Wet Dog Food

Compare Open Farm's Raw Lamb and Herring & Mackerel wet dog foods: ingredients, formats, feeding roles, and how to choose between them.

Two Open Farm cans, two different feeding roles

Open Farm's Raw Lamb and Herring & Mackerel wet foods look similar on the shelf, but they serve different purposes. The Raw Lamb is a 13.5 oz format built around a single animal protein with a long, ingredient-dense recipe. The Herring & Mackerel Stew is a 12.5 oz carton that combines two fish proteins with a shorter ingredient list and a clear combination-feeding instruction.

This comparison sticks to what the supplied product records confirm, so you can match the can to how you actually feed your dog.

What each recipe leads with

  • Open Farm Dog FD Raw Lamb Pasture-Raised 13.5 oz: Ingredients begin with Humanely Raised Lamb, Lamb Heart, Lamb Liver, and Ground Lamb Bone, followed by organic produce including carrots, blueberries, squash, spinach, kale, and cranberries. A lamb-first recipe with organ meats and bone suggests a muscle-meat-and-organ profile rather than a single-cut muscle food.
    Open Farm Dog FD Raw Lamb Pasture-Raised 13.5 oz
    Open Farm Dog FD Raw Lamb Pasture-Raised 13.5 oz
  • Open Farm Herring and Mackerel Stew 12.5oz: Ingredients begin with Herring, Water Sufficient for Processing, and Mackerel, followed by pumpkin, red lentils, spinach, green beans, chickpeas, and carrots. Two fish proteins plus water as the second ingredient point to a stew-style, moisture-rich format.
    Open Farm Herring and Mackerel Stew 12.5oz
    Open Farm Herring and Mackerel Stew 12.5oz

Format and moisture: 13.5 oz versus 12.5 oz

The Raw Lamb comes in a 13.5 oz can, while the Herring & Mackerel Stew is a 12.5 oz carton. That one-ounce difference matters less than what the guaranteed analysis tells you about moisture. The Herring & Mackerel Stew lists Moisture (max) 82%, which is typical for a stew. The supplied record for the Raw Lamb does not include a guaranteed analysis, so you cannot compare moisture or protein levels directly from the available information.

If you are choosing between the two for a dog who needs a higher-moisture meal, the Herring & Mackerel Stew gives you a confirmed number to work with. For the Raw Lamb, you would need to check the label on the can itself.

Guaranteed analysis and feeding instructions where supplied

  • Open Farm Herring and Mackerel Stew 12.5oz: Guaranteed Analysis: Crude Protein (min) 8%, Crude Fat (min) 3.5%, Crude Fiber (max) 2%, Moisture (max) 82%. Combination feeding: Reduce dry food by 2/3 cup for every 1 pack. These figures let you compare the stew to your dog's current food and adjust dry food when mixing.
  • Open Farm Dog FD Raw Lamb Pasture-Raised 13.5 oz: The supplied record lists ingredients but does not include a guaranteed analysis or feeding instructions. You cannot calculate a mix ratio or compare protein and fat levels for the Raw Lamb from the supplied information alone.

How to choose between lamb and fish

If your dog has eaten lamb-based foods before and you want a recipe built on a single animal protein with organ meats included, the Raw Lamb is the more direct match. Its ingredient list is longer and includes organic produce, coconut oil, salmon oil, and a range of supplements.

If you are looking for a fish-based stew to use as a complete meal or a topper, the Herring & Mackerel Stew gives you two fish proteins, a confirmed moisture level, and a clear instruction for reducing dry food when combining. That makes it easier to fold into a mixed feeding routine without guessing.

Neither can is positioned as a treatment or a veterinary diet in the supplied information. If your dog has a diagnosed condition or a strict prescription diet, those decisions belong with your veterinarian.

Side-by-side on the details that matter

  • Primary proteins: Raw Lamb: lamb (muscle, heart, liver, ground bone). Herring & Mackerel Stew: herring and mackerel.
  • Format and size: Raw Lamb: 13.5 oz can. Herring & Mackerel Stew: 12.5 oz carton.
  • Guaranteed analysis supplied: Herring & Mackerel Stew: protein 8% min, fat 3.5% min, fiber 2% max, moisture 82% max. Raw Lamb: not included in the supplied record.
  • Combination feeding guidance: Herring & Mackerel Stew: reduce dry food by 2/3 cup per pack. Raw Lamb: no combination guidance supplied.
  • Serving role stated: Herring & Mackerel Stew: serve as a complete and balanced meal or topper with Open Farm dry food. Raw Lamb: no serving role stated in the supplied record.

What the supplied information does not settle

The Raw Lamb record does not include a guaranteed analysis, feeding guidelines, or a calorie count. That means you cannot compare it to the Herring & Mackerel Stew on protein, fat, or calories using only the supplied information. The Herring & Mackerel Stew record does list 750 kcal/kg or 265 kcal per 354 g carton, which gives you a calorie reference for that recipe.

Neither record includes species or size compatibility statements, so this comparison cannot tell you whether one recipe suits a particular breed or life stage better than the other. Use the label on the product and your veterinarian's guidance for those decisions.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile